|8/2010 3:05:00 PM||Email this article • Print this article|
|IGH wood burners under fire
Homeowner claims ‘poison’ air
An outdoor wood burner nestled on a five-acre property in the southeast corner of Inver Grove Heights sent neighbors on Albavar Path packing to the city council Jan. 25 as though, well, they’d been smoked out.
Residents Armando and Nancy Lissarrague live on five acres next to a property that was purchased by the current owners in 2003. About 2 /2 years ago, Doug and Vivienne May, the Lissarrague’s newest neighbors, set up an auxiliary structure for woodworking, and installed a wood-burning furnace for their energy needs about 90 feet from the Lissarragues’ property line.
An outdoor wood-burning furnace, or an outdoor wood boiler, burns wood in a controlled combustion chamber resembling a small shed. The energy produced can heat water sent through underground pipes to heat a building, or be connected to a forced-air system. Smoke is released through a chimney attached to the chamber.
However, the "OWB"s can vary in efficiency, with the least efficient models producing volumes of smoke every day that can hover over the ground like a fog. More efficient models limit the amount of smoke produced, but burn through wood fuel more rapidly.
More than a dozen show
Lissarrague and the 15 or so neighbors who came to the meeting to support him and his wife are armed with information on wood smoke compiled by groups such as the American Lung Association, which claims that nitrogen oxides, a gas released during combustion, and particulate matter, or tiny particles of pollution suspended in air or water, are linked to respiratory disease and irritation.
The Environmental Protection Agency also claims that wood smoke contains harmful chemical gasses, and the accompanying soot contains particulate matter so small that it can pass into the lungs and blood stream and create or exacerbate health problems for the respiratory and coronary systems.
Numerous groups and coalitions have formed across the country in recent years to take on the passage of ordinances or outright bans on OWBs to address health and quality-of-life concerns, including Take Back the Air, an Edina-based group whose president, Julie Mellum, spoke at the meeting.
In response to their grievances, Lissarrague said the Mays were willing to raise the height of the smokestack, but were not willing to move the burner farther away from the property line. The Mays did not return calls by the South-West Review requesting an interview.
Lissarrague describes himself as easy to get along with, and said he is not out to cause undue problems for others. Ultimately, the issue is one of being a good neighbor, said Armando. At this point, the smoke is a nuisance, he told the council, and as a nuisance, the city has a right to regulate it through local ordinance.
He suggested a few options available to the council, such as regulating the distance a burner may be installed from a property line, but pleaded with them to ban wood burners entirely. "Ban outright –this is a solution that anyone living next to a neighbor with an outdoor wood burner would champion."
Bans in other cities
The city council of Austin rejected a proposed ban on outdoor wood burners in December of 2009.
Wyoming and Eagan are considering ordinances.
Lissarrague’s neighbor Gerald Biesterveld was one of the neighborhood supporters in attendance. While the smoke dissipates before hitting his property, Biesterveld told the council that when walking in the neighborhood, "if the smoke is just right, it will take the wind right out of you."
Mayor George Tourville directed the staff to put the issue on the first work session agenda of March, at which time staff will present more information on the merits or drawbacks of developing an ordinance to limit or ban OWBs inside city limits.
Danielle Cabot can be reached at email@example.com or 651-748-7815.
- A-B States = AL, AK, AZ, AR = Alabama, Alaska, Arizona, Arkansas
- C States = CA, CO, CT = California, Colorado, Connecticut
- DEF States = DE, DC, FL = Delaware, District of Columbia, Florida
- GHI States = GA, HI,, ID, IL, IN, IA = Georgia, Hawaii, Idaho, Illinois, Indiana, Iowa
- JKL States = KS, KY, LA = Kansas, Kentucky, Louisiana
- M1 ("Ma") States: ME, MD, MA = Maine, Maryland, Massachusetts
- M2 States = MI, MN = Michigan, Minnesota
- M3 States = MS, MO, MT = Mississippi, Missouri, Montana
- N ("New") States = NH, NJ, NM, NY = New Hampshire, New Jersey, New Mexico, New York
- N (not "New") States = NE, NV, NC, ND = Nebraska, Nevada, North Carolina, North Dakota
- O States = OH, OK, OR = Ohio, Oklahoma, Oregon
- PQR States = PA, RI = Pennsylvania, Rhode Island
- S-T States = SC, SD, TN, TX =South Carolina, South Dakota, Tennessee, Texas
- UVWXYZ States = UT, VT, VA, WA, WV, WI, WY = Utah, Vermont, Virginia, Washington State,West Virginia, Wisconsin, Wyoming
- Linda Karr’s invitation is awaiting your response
- Linda Karr’s invitation is awaiting your response
- Please stay in touch with me on LinkedIn
- (on the http://RAWSEP.wordpress.com site) USE THE SEARCH BOX to find WEEKLY RAWSEP, just type in WEEKLY RAWSEP and you will find WEEKLY RAWSEPS going back to March 8, 2010
- RAWSEP Residents Against Wood Smoke Emission Particulates LINKS